Lighting practice

7-Step Checklist for Vetting a Commercial LED Retrofit Quote

When this checklist applies

I've managed a lighting and electrical budget of roughly $180,000 a year for a 240-person B2B operation since 2021, and I've reviewed 40-plus retrofit quotes in that time. This checklist is for the moment a vendor hands you a proposal that mixes fixtures, controls, and labor into one lump-sum number. Office retrofits, warehouse upgrades, hallway refreshes—same logic applies. Seven steps, in the order I actually run them.

Step 1: Fix lumens, CRI, and beam angle before anyone mentions price

Watts are a proxy. Lumens are the deliverable. Before a vendor can quote, your spec needs three numbers locked: delivered lumens at the fixture (not the LED chip), CRI (90+ for offices and retail; 80 is fine in warehouses), and beam angle for anything directional. If the quote only says "50W equivalent," you're comparing marketing copy, not products.

Checkpoint: Ask for the photometric file (.ies) or at minimum the luminaire efficacy in lm/W. A 50W floodlight claiming 6,000 lumens is a very different product from one claiming 3,800.

Step 2: Reconcile model numbers, line by line

On a quote last spring, the line item read "6-inch LED downlight, 3000K, 1100lm." The submittal sheet named the LEDVANCE LED Performance Downlight G2. Good—except that product family ships in multiple lumen packages and trim finishes, and the quote didn't specify which. We caught it before ordering. A colleague at another site didn't, and ended up with 900lm units in a corridor spec'd for 1,100.

Same logic outdoors: an LEDVANCE Floodlight 50W is a specific product line. The 4000K and 5000K versions are different order codes. If your quote doesn't spell out the exact code, you don't know what you're buying.

Step 3: Trace the control signal from wall switch to driver

This is where budgets quietly fall apart. People assume smart lighting costs more because the hardware is expensive. Often it's the reverse—the fixture is the cheap part, and the real cost sits in commissioning, gateway setup, and making a wireless mesh behave inside a building with concrete cores and steel studs.

Ask for the control narrative in writing: which MCU Zigbee module sits inside each fixture, which Zigbee dimmer is on the wall, whether they run the same firmware, and who owns the gateway after handover. Zigbee 3.0 certification through the Connectivity Standards Alliance is the interoperability baseline; proprietary profiles are where trouble starts.

If the answer is "it just works," ask them to demonstrate it in your building—not in their showroom.

Step 4: Split hardware, labor, and commissioning into three numbers

A lump sum hides everything. I require three lines on every quote: fixture and control hardware, installation labor, and commissioning/configuration. That third line is the one vendors fold into "labor," and it's also the one that balloons when two control systems don't talk to each other.

For our last office floor, commissioning came to 14% of the total—or rather, 14% of what we ultimately paid, after two change orders. The first quote didn't show it at all. Not dishonesty—just how their template was built—but it meant we were comparing two different scopes. I'm not 100% sure the same split holds for very small jobs; on a 20-fixture project the commissioning line may be flat regardless of size.

We went with the mid-tier expedited option anyway (which, honestly, felt like paying a tax on someone else's scheduling problem).

Step 5: Match certifications to your rebate list

Per the DesignLights Consortium, commercial LED fixtures generally need to appear on the Solid-State Lighting Qualified Products List to qualify for most utility rebates. A fixture that's UL-listed but not DLC-listed may still be legal to install—it just won't get you the check. We missed a $2,300 rebate on a 2023 project because the specified downlight had dropped off the QPL two revisions earlier and nobody re-checked.

Pull the current QPL yourself. Don't take the vendor's word for it.

Step 6: Read the warranty at the component level

Most "5-year warranty" language—well, the headline number, anyway—covers the LED module. The driver is often a separate, shorter warranty: 3 years, sometimes prorated. Since drivers are the most common failure point in our buildings (we've replaced 11 across roughly 400 fixtures in three years), that distinction matters more than the headline number.

Ask two questions: what's the driver warranty, and can you buy replacement drivers as standalone parts in year four? If the answer to the second is no, you're buying a disposable fixture.

Step 7: Quote track lighting and other systems as separate scopes

If you're asking what is track lighting, the short version: it's a system, not a fixture—a powered mounting rail (the track) plus interchangeable heads that lock in and can be aimed independently. That's the whole point: you can re-aim or swap heads without re-wiring. It's also why track projects get quoted wrong, because the track, the heads, and the power feed are three line items that vendors sometimes compress into one.

If your project includes track, ask for track length, feed location, head count, and adapter type. Mixing track brands is possible but rarely clean. Same principle applies to any fixed system—get the components separated on paper before you compare prices.

Where this checklist breaks down

Two caveats before you run this. First, it assumes a mid-size commercial project with steady ordering—roughly 50 to 500 fixtures. If you're doing a single-room retrofit or a 5,000-fixture campus, the paperwork and the leverage are different. I can only speak to the mid-range.

Second, the checklist assumes you have room to ask questions. On our first LED project in 2021, I didn't. I approved a "plug-and-play Zigbee retrofit" based on a verbal assurance, then spent three weeks discovering that "compatible" meant "compatible after a firmware update the vendor charged $1,800 to perform." I now put the word compatible in quotes in every vendor email and make them define it in writing.

One more habit worth building: when I say "standard," I spell it out. Our maintenance team and a vendor once burned a week on "standard 4-foot," which to us meant T8 and to them meant T5. Same words, different products, empty fixture boxes in the hallway.

And on total cost: I don't count projected energy savings in a comparison unless the vendor provides the baseline operating hours and the utility rate they used. Otherwise it's a number someone typed into a spreadsheet. The quote is the quote; the projection is a conversation.

Keiko Mori

Keiko Mori

Keiko Mori is a luminaire safety and quality analyst specializing in general fixtures, emergency lights, exit signs, and supplier verification. She applies IEC 60598-1 and IEC 60598-2-22 to review dielectric strength, protective earthing, temperature rise, wiring, markings, battery duration, changeover operation, and test records. She writes structured compliance guides for quality and sourcing teams separating applicable construction evidence, declared configurations, installation conditions, and maintenance obligations from broad safety claims or incomplete documentation.